I am sensing a rising tide of ill-will toward Apple and AT&T with regard to the Iphone. Apple is typically quite adept at public relations, but I believe their moves with regard to tight control of the Iphone is beginning to get out of control.
One of the arguments against Apple has always been their control over their devices. With the Mac, I think it is a total non-issue. As an owner of three Macs, I can attest that I am not limited by anybody and can do anything I want with my computers. However, the Iphone is a pretty different story.
In terms of smartphones, the Iphone is revolutionary. I think it is the best smartphone on the market, although the Palm Pre might have the potential of giving the Iphone a run for the money. The Iphone craze, though, is well deserved.
But, the major drawbacks with the device come down to direct decisions by Apple:
- Apple has to approve each and every app in the App Store. Their reasoning to approving or not approving apps seems to be disjointed and inconsistent. It also seems to take forever sometimes.
- Apple’s deal to tie the phone to AT&T has been a real problem. AT&T has simply not been able to keep up with the Iphone. The latest Iphone 3GS has capabilities that you can’t even tap into because of AT&T network limitations. Complaints about dropped calls is high. Complaints about lack of MMS are resounding, considering even some of the cheapest phones out there can do MMS while the Iphone still cannot because of AT&T.
Steven Frank, an Iphone app developer at Panic, recently wrote a very hard-hitting post declaring that he is quitting the Iphone. For him, the final straw was Apple rejecting all Google Voice apps from the App Store. In fact, the rejection even included Google Voice apps that had already been approved. They just went in there and retroactively removed them.
And let’s look at that for a moment…
You can get Blackberries on AT&T with apps for Google Voice. There are other apps in the App Store which could potentially conflict with AT&T services. There has been a lot of speculation as to whether it was Apple or AT&T which triggered the rejections, but I think one thing is very clear: This was profit motivated and NOT in the best interest of Iphone owners. From all appearances, this was a “stick it to Google” move.
The App Store approval process is nothing but a HUGE boondoggle. I personally have a friend who is STILL waiting for Apple to approve or give any word whatsoever on a new app. It has been FIVE WEEKS. He’s heard nothing. So, timing is inconsistent. Apple’s own reasons for doing things seems to be purposely hidden while also being inconsistent. And app developers are left in the dark.
Steven Frank ended his post with these comments:
I realize these actions are utterly insignificant to Apple. I know I’m a tiny tadpole flapping his tail helplessly in anger at the ocean. But at least my conscience is clear. I hope change is coming. I’m really going to miss my iPhone terribly. I’m frustrated and disappointed at the whole situation.
I think this sums up a rising sentiment. Apple appears to make it’s Iphone decisions to suit one party: Apple. And when customers feel insignificant to Apple, THAT’S A PROBLEM. No customer should feel like a “tiny tadpole”.
Apple needs to loosen up on the Iphone. And it needs to ditch the AT&T contract. That contract is set to be renewed in 2010, and if Apple renews that contract, expect a mass exodus from the Iphone. Because that will have proved that Apple doesn’t care about it’s customers.
Speaking for myself, I still like my Iphone. However, I don’t want my hands artificially tied by a company only looking out for profits at the expense of their customer. The attractiveness of jail-breaking my phone is looking better and better every day. I haven’t done it yet, however if Apple keeps making decisions which seem only to be self-preserving, I might very well make the move.
Like what you read?
If so, please join over 28,000 people who receive our exclusive weekly newsletter and computer tips, and get FREE COPIES of 5 eBooks we created, as our gift to you for subscribing. Just enter your name and email below:
You’re last line is something that has been intriguing me for weeks. I hope you can write an article on the pros and cons of jailbreaking one’s iPhone.
I’m having a problem being sympathetic towards people who bought what is essentially an expensive toy for adult boys. I have seen children whine less about their toys that did not work exactly as they would like them to.
As Timmay says, if your toy does not work as you would like it to then fix it with a hack.
People don’t get the whole iPhone phenomenon; it’s not a fad, it not an expensive toy, it is the future of all wireless devices that can be carried in our pocket. I avoided the iPhone for two years, but I owned many iPods including the touch, and finally decided I would move up to an iPhone. While it lacks some basic things my Windows Mobile phone can easily do, there are many, many benefits it provides. People can literally have nothing but an iPhone and nothing else. No need for a laptop or internet connection at home, no need for a digital camera or camcorder; the iPod addresses all of these and provides a phone.
So, I am sure you cannot understand, but no one is asking for sympathy. All that iPhone users are asking for is what Apple and AT&T promised to delivery on 2 years ago, and that is why both companies have, and will continue to do so as more people buy iPhones.
agree. ATT wins hands down as the worst company. No comparison. Twice as expensive. I plan on unlocking my IPhone immediately else just rhrown it away or sell it, I have had it a month and like it but have come to despise ATT and was warned against them.
The latest iPhone jail breaking software is already here.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-10301310-1.html
Here is the latest news on Google Voice:
http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/169449/fcc_questions_apple_over_google_voice.html
You are absolutely right.. Apple and AT&T seems to be ruining the life of iPhone. such a nice gem and these people just for profit are not letting us take any advantage. I am from India though but here its again the same case. The carriers are so pathetic that we are not able to get an iPhone which has been publicized by Apple over the two years.
Just about everyone I know jailbreaks there iphone. I have a Blackberry 9530 (Storm) with VZW. AT&T is just crap and so is the iphone. Get a better device.