Ditch The Slack [Camcorders]

Posted Feb 20, 2009 by Rich Menga  

The days of linear format camcorders are dying. Linear as it relates to camcorders is anything using slack that requires rewinding or fast-forwarding. And to be honest I’m not sorry to see them go. This is more or less the last in line of tech products to get "off the slack", so to speak.

There are many of you out there who still have MiniDV videocassette format camcorders. Since day one I have always hated MiniDV. It’s not the cassette itself I hate, it’s the fact the decks in camcorders that use them are notoriously unreliable. This is partly due because of the cookie-cutter style method of manufacturing that goes into these things (even the expensive ones).

For those that remember VHS camcorders, those things were built like tanks and lasted a good long time. You could pop in and out VHS tapes to your heart’s content and it wouldn’t bust.

MiniDV on the other hand is something you have to treat gingerly. It’s almost as if you have to say a little prayer each time you load in a cassette. "Oh please, don’t break on me. Pretty please. I treat you well. You know I do." Your prayers won’t matter because your MiniDV camcorder can and will break at the worst possible time and is very subject to Murphy’s Law.

Fortunately it’s relatively cheap to ditch the slack, say buh-bye to MiniDV and go with non-linear flash, optical or hard disk camcorders.

For the vast majority of you that do non-pro video recording, a Flip will work. I personally have one of these things. The fact I can get 60 minutes of very decent quality record time on a unit powered by two AA batteries is nothing short of miraculous. Granted, the zoom feature sucks and it can’t do close-ups very well, but the convenience more than makes up for it. And it even has a tripod mount. Currently they sell for just under $130. And yes, you should get one. By the way, the USB port on it is built in.

"But I need better quality", you say. Then go with optical (or more specifically, the 8cm DVD disc format). For under $300 you can get yourself quite a nice Canon.

"But I hate discs", you say. Then go with hard-disk based units. These aren’t cheap. The lowest price is just a tick under $350. From there they spike over $600 easily. Do they have the super-awesome quality you’re looking for? Absolutely. It is for all intents and purposes a pro-grade unit.

Ditch your MiniDV and step into the modern age. It’s time.

Which Of These Traits Applies To YOUR Computing Life?...

2 Responses to “Ditch The Slack [Camcorders]”

  1. Chris Cliff says:

    I agree that it will be nice to upgrade to a HDD camera when our mini-dv finally gives in. It truly is amazing how much storage they are cramming into the cameras these days.

    Now if the optics were just a bit better life would be good.

  2. Drew says:

    Rich, doesn’t MiniDV give you an overall better quality picture though? I read somewhere that the problem with the flash/HDD camcorders (HDD is actually my preference also) is that the compression is much greater than the MiniDV’s. Do you think it’s a noticeable difference, if any?

    I’m in the research stage myself, and really want to get a hi-def HDD camera, but hearing/reading about some compression “issues” that you don’t get w/ MiniDV…. *confused*

Leave a Reply