CLOSE

You've Found Us! Now Stay Connected...

Sign Up for PCMech.com's FREE weekly newsletter. We'll help keep you informed on what's happening in the world of technology.


Privacy Policy | More Information

PCMech.com helps normal people get their geek on. We talk about computers, technology, the Internet, social media - anything that makes a geek feel warm and fuzzy inside.

Home | About | Newsletter | Forums | Advertise! | Store | Wordpress Help | Log in

Helping Normal People Get Their Geek On

Trouble at Wikipedia

About this Post

Posted Dec 4, 2007
PCMech Wire

About the Author

David Risley is the founder of PCMech.com. He is the brains, the thinker, the writer, the nerd.
David's Website
David on Twitter
David on FriendFeed

The Register has posted an interesting story about the internal politics at Wikipedia. As the story puts it:

Controversy has erupted among the encyclopedia’s core contributors, after a rogue editor revealed that the site’s top administrators are using a secret insider mailing list to crackdown on perceived threats to their power.

Do we have a Wikipedia ruling class? A group of Wikipedia editors trying to maintain tight control over the content of the famous online encyclopedia?

Much of the internal uproar apparently started with the actions of one of the admins called "Durova". She banned another Wikipedia editor now referred to as "Bang Bang". Durova claimed this user was a troublemaker intent on destroying Wikipedia, saying ""He is a ripened sock with a padded history of redirects, minor edits, and some DYK work. He also indulges in obscene trolling in German, and free range sarcasm and troublemaking. If you find this user gloating, or spot his nasty side, hit him with the banhammer."

The evidence Durova had was apparently held secret until someone (apparently not happy about it) leaked one of the private emails of Durova. This private email revealed that there was a secret mailing list. In the leaked email, Durova says that Bang Bang IS a wonderfully productive editor, that the public disgrace was a fake, and that she thought Bang Bang was trying to get on the good side of the community in order to take it down from within.

Sounds like Durova is paranoid. Seen the movie Conspiracy Theory lately? Saw what happened to Mel Gibson?

Durova has since resigned her admin powers at Wikipedia, and the Arbitration Committee has admonished her "to exercise greater care when issuing blocks". Yeah.

Oh, and the super secret mailing list is hosted by Wikia. Right here, to be exact.

Is Wikipedia getting too big for itself? Is the popularity of the site giving rise to a select few who are trying to keep tight control over the information on the site? Sounds to me like the team there is starting to take themselves a little too seriously.

Subscribe To the PCMech Feed for more interesting posts and exclusive feed-only freebies. Our weekly newsletter will keep you up to date each week.

2 Trackback(s)

  1. Google Knol to Compete with Wikipedia » PC Mechanic on Dec 15, 2007
  2. Wikipedia Accuracy: Dave Winer’s Criticism » PCMech on Mar 26, 2008

Post a Comment

Now Playing on PCMech Video

Feature ImageHow-To: Make a Super-Fast Pie Chart

Feature ImageMicrosoft Worldwide Telescope

See All Videos | PCMech Channel Youtube Channel

Free Weekly Newsletter

Sign up! Exclusive weekly content, weekly rant, and more!

Name:
Email: | Privacy Policy
  | See Also Online Business Club

Subscribe to PCMech Feed

Subscriber Feed More Info

Or, via email. Exclusive, Feed-Only Content.

Sponsor


Recent Visitors