XP Downgrade Rights Extended Until.. 2020?

From the You Have Got To Be Kidding Me department, certain folks are thrilled that Microsoft just extended downgrade rights…

for Windows XP.

We’re gonna need two facepalms for this one.

DoubleFacePalm

Of course, these "certain folks" I’m referring to aren’t home computer users but rather businesses. It also indicates that Microsoft will by 2020 have been officially supporting the XP OS for 19 years.

I want to make clear that the official extended support for XP will still end in 2014, but as long as Microsoft allows a downgrade from 7 to XP, that is technically supporting the XP OS even if only to a very limited degree.

If you’re thinking that 19 years is the longest stretch Microsoft has ever supported a specific version of Windows, you’re right. The previous longest stretch was for Windows 3.1. It was introduced originally in 1992, continued to be produced long after PC support ended and was used in embedded devices until 2008 (16 years).

Now you may be thinking, "Maybe businesses just want to save a buck by not purchasing new Windows licenses." You would be wrong there. This is a downgrade option. It means the customer has the option after purchasing a Windows 7 license to downgrade to XP, so the money for the license is still spent regardless.

You may also have the thought of, "Windows 7 has much higher hardware requirements than XP, and that’s a concern, right?" Not really. Windows 7 will run flawlessly on something even as low-powered hardware-wise as a netbook – with Aero interface mind you. Put another way, you can load 7 on a single-core 1.6GHz with 1GB RAM and a 20GB hard drive with no problem at all and use it normally. That’s 10-year-old specs for a desktop right there, and 7 will run on it easily.

Now you’re probably wondering why businesses would stick with XP at all.

There are four primary reasons why.

  1. Legacy support.
  2. Avoidance of retraining employees on a new OS.
  3. Avoidance of having to rewrite existing documentation.
  4. Avoidance of having to run a mixed-OS environment.

Per point 1, there are many apps programmed within companies called "home grown" programs. They are usually buggy nasty things that barely run on XP, so they’re pretty much guaranteed not to run on 7 at all.

Per point 2, employees appreciate routine, routine and more routine. Throw anything into the mix that’s different, and Gertrude at the front desk will freak out. "WHERE’S MY START BUTTON?! I CAN’T DO ANYTHING WITHOUT MY START BUTTON!" Yes, this really happens.

Per point 3, a new OS requires new documentation on how to do specific things in it, and nobody wants to deal with rewriting any of that. Yes, that means that companies are lazy.

Per point 4, it’s most likely true companies would not upgrade all the boxes to 7 all at once but rather do it one department at a time. At that point you have roughly a six month to a year’s worth of a mixed-OS environment, and that plays hell both the workforce and tech support every time it happens.

Even though all the above is 100% true, I still think it’s a seriously stupid idea that Microsoft has decided to allow this beast called XP to last until 2020. I’m sure that someone at Redmond thought it was a swell idea to extend support of an OS for 19 years, but the rest of us are left shaking our heads in disbelief.

Why do you think Microsoft extended the downgrade option up to 2020? To appease the corporate customer base? To cash in on legacy-leeches? How truly "ready" does a company have to be before they can start using 7?

Let us know by writing a comment or two.

Free eBook!

Like what you read?

If so, please join over 28,000 people who receive our exclusive weekly newsletter and computer tips, and get FREE COPIES of 5 eBooks we created, as our gift to you for subscribing. Just enter your name and email below:

Post A Comment Using Facebook

  • http://davidrisley.com David Risley

    Perhaps I'm wrong here, but offering option to downgrade doesn't necessarily mean they're supporting it. I could be one of these, “Sure, we'll take your money and let you do it, but you're on your own” things. Who knows.

    • http://menga.net Rich Menga

      Support officially ends in 2014 for XP unless Microsoft changed their tune there for whatever reason – but it's confirmed the option to downgrade from 7 to XP will exist until 2020.

  • Kidd

    Rich, great article. The history of the allowable downgrades from MS puts everything in context, but you hit the nail on the head with points 1,2,3 and 4. My company doesn't have much that #3 applies to, but that doesn't mean it won't be a problem for many others.

    Point 1: Legacy Software is sometimes necessary, and XP mode Virtual Machine takes care of this, but can be a pain. (my XP mode takes longer to start than the real computer, because Win7 fires up pretty fast)
    Points 2, and 4: My company is in a mixed OS environment, and it sucks. I enjoy Win7, so much that I no longer use XP on any home PC or my work PC. There are a few in my company that don't use a home PC, and XP is the only thing they know. When something goes wrong, I've forgotten how to fix XP problems, because I haven't used it in so long. Now that Win7 has been out for a while and I've hashed all of the issues of working with it, I don't want to go back. The people who barely know how to use their OS certainly don't want to learn anything new, as most people perceive change as a bad thing (Double Facepalm).

  • None

    I still like XP…glad to see it 'hanging on' a little longer!

    I have used Vista and Windows 7 and I have to say that my XP system is rock solid compared to Vista and 7. Obviously we all know the problems with Vista, but I find 7 just as 'buggy'.

  • David M.

    The business owners that I know that use XP are not changing it because they have no need to…its that simple.

    • Kidd

      And it costs money. That's why the majority of companies won't change, is because reasons #2 & 3 above will cost a company money. Am I missing another reason for this?

      I still wouldn't have Win7 at work if I hadn't justified the need for a 64 bit OS, and XP64 support will be ending long before the workstation's life. But paying for a license and downgrading to 9 year-old OS seems unnecessary to me.

    • AllanH

      Well said David M. At 73 I have used computers since beginning with a HP 9825 all the way to XP. Every change has meant a relearn. I still dont know much about XP – but enough to suit my small business/home use. It does all I require so my last 2 comp were bought BECAUSE they had XP, (one with vista upgrade discs supplied which I wont use).

      Its OK for young nerds who like challenge and can adapt but it is my impression a user referendum on 'STAY' or 'CHANGE' would be lost to 'STAY'. That would extend to other sofware – OFFICE for example.
      Take note Bill Gates!

  • David

    It doesn't make sense to me, for for Microsoft or for businesses. But I don't see any reason to get up in arms over it.

    Home grown buggy, nasty things??? Only with poor developers. And that happens everywhere, not just with home grown. But the fact is, most of them grew up on the NT line, and work fine. So for business to invest in upgrading the OS and upgrading the software….just so they can work EXACTLY the SAME…there's just no incentive. Unless you can really pitch something else with the upgrade…

  • stu

    XP is rock solid here. Ran 7 in a virtual box for a while. Nice, but it doesn't do anything new for me that I can't already do. Staying where I am for now and watching. Won't go mac, but might think about ubuntu. Got till 2014 to think about it.

  • Wayneduranmd

    mom and pop business like mine with an XP based medical records and billing program would have to spend thousands of dollars to dump the software it took 3 years to master and find a sub with probably another 3 years of learning to look forward to. Don't forget, most business in the US is small, read necessarily frugal, not lazy! WD

    • http://menga.net Rich Menga

      Who said you had to dump any software? Server farm it and then the OS on the local desktop doesn't matter and you don't have to relearn anything. Use Citrix XenApp (they even have a trial edition you can use right now). And yes, it's affordable. If you have no idea how to use it or just want someone to come in and set it up, hire a consultant from RHI.

What’s Your Preference?

Daily Alerts

Each day we send out a quick email to thousands of PCMECH readers to notify them of new posts. This email is just a short, plain email with titles and links to our latest posts. You can unsubscribe from this service at any time.

You can subscribe to it by leaving your email address in the following field and confirming your subscription when you get an email asking you to do so.

Enter your email address for
Daily Updates:

Weekly Newsletter

Running for over 6 years, the PCMECH weekly newsletter helps you keep tabs on the world of tech. Each issue includes news bits, an article, an exclusive rant as well as a download of the week. This newsletter is subscribed to by over 28,000 readers (many who also subscribe to the other option) - come join the community!

To subscribe to this weekly newsletter simply add your email address to the following field and then follow the confirmation prompts. You will be able to unsubscribe at any time.

Enter your email address for
Free Weekly Newsletter: