ADSL Modem Woes - Follow up!

[mrstarface]

OK went to install mt adsl modem in anticipation of getting broadband this wednesday.

Should have known it wouldnt have gone easily, bloody pc things never do.

I bought the (admittedly cheap) conexant pci adsl modem from e-buyer for about 30 quid. As soon as I put it in its slot and tried to switch the pc on nothing happens. So i try moving it to another slot and same thing happens. But when I take it out the computer starts no problem!? Basically as soon as its put it in the pc refuses to power up.

Tried it in mates pc as well and the same thing happened to him.

WTF is going on?! I could understand the modem not working but not actually even letting the pc boot up?

Anyone know if this has happened to them, I assume I'll have to return it as its faulty.

Should I stick with the pci modem, mate says that a usb one is a lot less hassle and I see his point, as you dont have to bugger about opening the pc and leave a slot free.

Sigh now I wont be able to get another modem in time for wenesday after weeks of waiting. Bugger

[mrstarface]

Looking into it further would it make sense to buy a router instead of a adsl modem? Do they do the same thing so I can plug the line straight into a router and use it like a modem but also share the connection with my mates by them attaching to the other ports?!

[Blakhart]

If you game, you would want the pci version. That way there is no latency in movement or commands due an external modem/router and cabling. If not, a router will add a very stout layer of security. A good firewall would round it out.

I suspect that there may be a problem with that particular pci modem, and you should send it back. Anything that is pci and halts the system is most likely dead.
My .02

[Tuf]

You need a modem whether you use a router or not. If decide to use a router you'll need an external ethernet modem that works with your ISP.
The function of a router is so you can connect multiple computers to one internet connection and setup a lan if you choose to. If you only have one computer you don't really need a router unless you want the NAT protection that it provides(good thing).
You will still need a nic (network card) in each computer.
So in essence you will have your phone line (DSL) coming to the modem, a cat5 cable to the router, and a cat5 cable to each nic. If you don't use a router the cat5 cable from the modem will go to the nic in your computer.

[glc]

Unfortunately, the best way to go in the UK is with a USB DSL modem.

[Tuf]

Can they not get them or is nobody supplying them? Either it way that stinks! USB is good for mice.

[glc]

I believe the UK providers must be trying to make it difficult for the customer to share the connection on purpose.

Tuf: just look at TwoRails' setup for evidence of that.

[Tuf]

glc:
I agree something is not right with TwoRails' ISP. Either they want him to move over to the newer technology or they just inherited a system they know nothing about. Either way it amounts to some crappy service.