Poll: DS or PSP

[Darth Revan]

Which would you buy. I was looking into getting a handheld game player. And couldn't decide which one. Would you all give me your opinions on which you would choose, and the reasons why. I was especially wondering which has better image/graphics quality. Any input is appreciated.
Thanx

[shadowbreaker513]

Niether right now. The DS has limited games, sub par graphics, and bad controls. The PSP has too many problems to list. Wait until the gen2 PSPs come out to see if the problems are corrected.

[kram 2.0]

Right now, PSP due to plain versatility but Gameboy DS isn't far off the picture, I'd say. Wait a while, regardless - PSP needs games, and so does Gameboy DS.

kram

[New Guy Jr]

I am leaning towards the Sony. Nintendo has really pushed me away. I got the Gameboy advanced and Gamecube and I am really diappointed with the few number of games that are aimed at adults. It seams that most games are Pokimon or other kiddie oriented.

On the other hand, I am waiting until Sony gets their quality under control. I have heard that 8 dead pixles is common and their return policy is that they will not accept returns for dead pixles!

[Hi Ho]

I think the PSP has a lot more going for it. I'm not a fan of the games available for any Nintendo system. I have a feeling that the game library for the PSP will grow fast. Faster then that of the DS. Plus you get MP3 and movie playback with the PSP.

Where have you read about PSP problems Shadow? I haven't been able to find much on the PSP.

[04nmr85]

I would also go with the PSP. It looks like it has some amazing graphics and there seems to be a lot of games out for the launch. I work at kmart and we had some where around 15 or 20. Not to mention it serves as a MP3 player and a movie player.

I haven't heard anything about the PSP problems either Shadow. I'm kind of intereseted tho.

[shadowbreaker513]

Originally Posted by Hi Ho I think the PSP has a lot more going for it. I'm not a fan of the games available for any Nintendo system. I have a feeling that the game library for the PSP will grow fast. Faster then that of the DS. Plus you get MP3 and movie playback with the PSP. Where have you read about PSP problems Shadow? I haven't been able to find much on the PSP.

35% dead pixel rate
Square button pad under screen and easily cracks
UMD dics shooting out the back
Measily 4 hour battery life
Comes from factory with dust under screen
Some units don't work with USB
None of those things are covered under warrenty.

[Tin]

you guys are missing the concept of the DS. DS is basically a test peripheral...Nintendo has no intentions of it going very far. its not even a Gameboy iteration, just a test peripheral. the next Gameboy should be out sometime in late '06 early '07. Nintendo created their own version of the Palm OS to work with DS. Nintendo is also implementing many wireless access points around the globe so DS can be played against anybody around the world (providing theyre near one of the access points). for PSP, you must be located somewhere near a wireless router in order to play online against somebody. DS also has many other uses, such as GPS, remote control, instant messenger, automobile tuning software, etc. it doesnt surprise me that Nintendo announced the full capabilities of the DS weeks prior to the PSP launch. nobody knew the DS was capable of so much until recently. dont get me wrong, i think PSP will have the better games, but for overall functionality, the DS is the winner. ill probably like the DS games better anyway...nothing like just a plain fun Nintendo game like Mario Kart, Metroid, Zelda, Smash Bros, Wario Ware...just simple fun.

EDIT: heres a good read http://www.pdastreet.com/articles/20...do-DS-PDA.html

[New Guy Jr]

Here is a link to another discussion on the PSP:
http://forums.dvdfile.com/interactiv...ad.php?t=53251

Dust, hairs, and crud found under the plastic sheild? Sony should be ashamed!

[GForce64]

Originally Posted by New Guy Jr It seams that most games are Pokimon or other kiddie oriented.

Oriented, yes. But things are not always what they seem.
Edit: Sorry about that. Anyway, click on egervari's FAQ here

[Yuanji]

PSP W/O a doubt. First of all, I have no idea what Nintendo is smoking but it has to be something good. First of all, no new games are slated for DS until next year or at least no major games. Also, Nintendo is going to try to market a next Gameboy because the DS is not the next handheld system from Nintendo and I have no idea how they are going to work out having 2 handhelds from the same company coming out with games that are acceptable. PSP has better graphics then DS, and is much more revolutioniary using memory rather then the built in memory in the game cartridges. The touch screen is just a gimmick and doesn't even work well. The only thing i can think that the touch screen actually makes sense in is Metroid Prime: Hunters. DS also has no analogue stick which i feel is completely unacceptable in games these days.

^ Geforce64, you cannot link directly to a file on gamefaqs because they want to preserve bandwith. Please link to the faq where you found the file.

[shadowbreaker513]

The touch screen is horrible for Metriot, trust me, I've played it. Only reason I can find to get a DS is for the new Advance Wars gaming coming out. Advance Wars 2 is the only reason I still have a GBA. Final Fantasy Tactics Advance used to be reason #2, but then my dog ate it.

[Tin]

i have a feeling PSP will go the way of the Game Gear. theres much more to DS than meets they eye. Warp Pipe is going to be awesome. play multiplayer games against others around the world from virtually anywhere. theres a plus to using a cartidge...your memory is expandable...which it isnt on PSP. remember...graphics dont make games. think about it in terms of women...the hottest one isnt necessarily the best one. you want one that can cook and clean house too .

[vödka]

PSP, hands down! Graphics are waaay better, and watching movies on the PSP is very cool... the DS is a cheap toy for kids... IMO

[Hi Ho]

your memory is expandable...which it isnt on PSP

The PSP accepts MemorySticks which come in 1GB sizes.

[icallmedan]

I bought a PSP the day after launch, against my better judgement. I thought, what the heck I have a bunch of old game stuff in the basment and I could get a fair amount in trade in. I bought it, and I am very surprised. It is a lot better than expected. Everything on it works. I think there are one or two dead pixels near the edge of the screen, but that doesn't bother me because you can only see them in the main menu. As soon as you start playing the game, you are immersed in what you are doing and you dont notice. Also the games are fun. I have THUG 2 Remix and Ridge Racer, and I am surprised at how fun they are to play. THUG 2 made a 2 hour ride to Maryland seem like nothing. Up until this point I have never owned anythign from Sony. I had an Xbox and a GBA. Now I own a PSP, and I am very pleased. People say the $250 is alot to spend on a system, but the extra $50 (over the japanese price) comes from all of the extras you get. Sony wanted you to get the full experience of the system with the "Value Pack" and I believe that you do. You get a case, earbud headphones w/remote, a cleaning cloth, a video and music sampler, spiderman 2, and a 32Mb memory stick. I find the case and earbuds especially necessary for what I need it. The case protects my $250 investment, obviously, and the earbuds keeps the sounds out of my parents ears!

I was skeptical too, but this system is great. Graphics and games are amazing, and there are many more to come.

Tin said that PSP will go the way of the GameGear, but I think that that is untrue. As much as people hate to admit it (and I would have to, having never owned a Sony product) Sony has a very large fan base. Overtime they will sell more systems and more games will continue to be released. People were skeptical that the original Play Station would cut into Nintendo's profits, and look what they Play Station name has turned into.

Also, it was mentioned that Nintendo has plans to make the DS a PDA or whatever. This may be an added feature, but people buy a portable gaming system to game. Even with the PSP, no one really bought it as an MP3 player or a Movie player. Yes, you can use it for that, but it is not the main use. Just as people won't buy a DS to use it as a PDA, yes you can use it for that, but it is a gaming machine.

Speaking game machine vs. game machine, PSP is a much better option.

[drew.]

I agree with everything icall said, plus the online features of this thing are amazing. And using the firefox hack you can search the web in the palm of your hands, nintindo has gone soft and makes kiddie games anyways.

[icallmedan]

I like your location Mike...lol.

[drew.]

hehe, ya theres nothing better than playing tm online

[Tin]

from www.gameboy-advance.net

Nintendo DS Satellite Tuner / VoIP / Presenter / Car PC

XM/Sirius Tuner : A satellite tuner for your favorite satellite product. It would come complete with a channel browser that resembles a cable television channel guide. It would benefit from DS's mobility and long battery life as well as great sound quality. You would have to of course pay for your own XM or Sirius subscription.

VOIP DS : Voice Over IP software for your Nintendo DS. Get all the advantages of Voice Over IP in a portable format. Use a repeater in the house or have a nationally based service that allows you to use your DS as a phone (wireless voip). Nintendo DS would be one of the first products to utilize IPv6 to do its networking. When further developments come forward, the DS will be able to use a camera product in combination with the VOIP software that will allow it to be the first ever Wireless Video Phone. Talk to your friends and colleagues face to face over the Nintendo DS.

Presenter DS : An ultra portable projector for your Nintendo DS. The projector would be HDTV compliant using the latest 1080i features. Cram your important presentations into the smallest possible portable projector/project presentation medium ever. The touch pad and stylus can even operate as an interactive part of your presentation. No longer will you have to stand by the screen to point out highlights and key topics of your presentation. Simply use the touch pad to draw your audience's attention to important notes.

Vehicle Computer DS : Performance car monitor. Hook your DS into a harness for your performance vehicle and be able to monitor fuel mixtures, efficiency levels, gear ratios, and four wheel drive options. Now use your DS to peak your vehicle to top performance at a fraction of the price of expensive car computers. When you are done use your saved data to analyze to bring even more performance to your car.

Sony what...?

EDIT: wow looks like PDA software is in the making for NDS too http://www.gameboy-advance.net/ninte...cketpc-pda.htm .

[Jaggannath]

Since the time of the N64 I've been disappointed with Nintendo's game-making focus... they usually bring out about 1/3 of the games Sony did, and although there are some classics, I could more easily justify to myself buying a Sony, as I feel they've done more to help their users (I've never owned a Sony, btw)

[icallmedan]

Tin I take it you have a DS?

[kram 2.0]

I wonder what Microsoft has up its sleeve with Nintendo and Sony shifting to handheld...

kram

[vödka]

Originally Posted by kram8806 I wonder what Microsoft has up its sleeve with Nintendo and Sony shifting to handheld... kram

lol, would be cool to see what xbox would look like as a handheld... till then I will be playing my PSP.

[drew.]

Originally Posted by kram8806 I wonder what Microsoft has up its sleeve with Nintendo and Sony shifting to handheld... kram

i was thinking that same thing erlier today, but seeing as how xbox two already has some shortcomings, i doubt it could compete with psp. Itll be fun to see what microsoft will do though.

[Hi Ho]

Halo on the go! That would be great! I'm sure they will come up with something. I have never owned a portable game system but with the recent advances they are becoming more and more enticing.

[drew.]

ya halo 2 on a wireless microsoft handheld would be worth paying big bucks for. I love seeing this advancement of graphics on handhelds, compare a regular gameboy to a psp, WOW has technology advanced

[Tin]

Originally Posted by icallmedan Tin I take it you have a DS?

not yet...ill probably pick one up down the line. i just like Nintendo's games better. i could spend all day playing Zelda, Smash Bros, Wario Ware, Mario Golf, etc. the only games ive ever liked by Sony were Syphon Filter and the Gran Tourismo series. Gran Tourismo for PSP looks like a hell of a game, but i wont go out of my way to get a PSP for it. Ridge Racer is pretty damn cool...spent about an hour playing that. my main complaint about PSP, the short battery life. that thing eats batteries like a fat kid eats a Big Mac. DS on the other hand...the buttons are too damn small and close together. PSP overall is the most comfortable to play on, but it just dont have the functionality of a DS.

[drew.]

Originally Posted by Tin my main complaint about PSP, the short battery life. that thing eats batteries like a fat kid eats a Big Mac.

Its acctually not as bad as most people percieve, ive played mine the last 2 days for like a total of 6 hours of twisted metal, and had to charge only last night. Plus the charging time is quick. Ds to me just seems like a kiddies toy with all those type games. Dont get me wrong zelda is probually my favorite series of all time, with the snes game my favorite game of all time, but some of those games are just too elementary.

just my 2 cents

[Yuanji]

Originally Posted by kram8806 I wonder what Microsoft has up its sleeve with Nintendo and Sony shifting to handheld... kram

microsoft will counter your puny handheld systems with a newer, buggier OS!!! We'll make trillions on tech support! *evil laugh*